Thick, creamy, and made to order, the Five Guys Milkshake has become one of the restaurant’s signature desserts. Unlike many fast-food chains that rely on pre-mixed machines, Five Guys hand-spins every shake using a rich vanilla base and lets customers customize it with complimentary mix-ins. From classic favorites like Oreo® Cookie Pieces and Peanut Butter to Coffee, Salted Caramel, Bacon, and fresh fruit, every shake can be personalized to suit your taste.
Whether you’re comparing Five Guys Milkshake prices, checking Five Guys Milkshake calories, exploring nutrition facts, or looking for the best mix-in combinations, understanding the menu before you order makes it easier to choose a shake that matches both your taste and dietary preferences.
With dozens of possible mix-in combinations and fresh preparation for every order, Five Guys offers one of the most customizable milkshake experiences among major fast-casual burger chains.
Five Guys Milkshakes Menu
Milkshake
Milkshake—creamy, rich, and perfectly sweet.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Coffee
Made with a premium syrup for a rich, bold coffee flavor.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Bananas
Banana marinade with simple syrup.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Strawberries
Strawberry marinade with simple syrup.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Oreo® Cookies
Crushed and oh-so-sweet Oreo* Cookie pieces.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Peanut Butter
Natural, creamy peanut butter with a touch of honey.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Bacon
Crispy, sweet Applewood smoked bits of bacon.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
REESE’S Cups
REESE’S classic combination of chocolate and peanut butter.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Chocolate
Chocolate and fudge for a double chocolate punch.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Oreo® Crème
The cream of an Oreo® separated for a sweeter, creamier shake.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Salted Caramel
Sweet and creamy caramel with a savory kick.
$5.85 | Cal 670-1400
Five Guys Milkshake Nutrition Calculator
Why Five Guys Milkshakes Are Different
Five Guys doesn’t offer a long list of pre-designed milkshake flavors. Instead, every shake starts with the same premium vanilla base and is blended by hand after you order.
This made-to-order preparation creates a thick, creamy texture while allowing every customer to customize their drink with complimentary mix-ins. Rather than choosing from fixed menu options, you build your own combination using ingredients like Oreo® Cookie Pieces, Peanut Butter, Coffee, Chocolate, Salted Caramel, Banana, Strawberries, Bacon, and more.
That flexibility is one of the biggest reasons the Five Guys Milkshake continues to rank among the most popular desserts at major burger chains.
Five Guys Milkshake Price
Although prices vary slightly by location, a regular Five Guys Milkshake generally costs between $5.99 and $7.49.
Unlike many restaurants that charge extra for flavor additions, Five Guys includes complimentary mix-ins in the price, allowing you to customize your shake without paying for each ingredient.
| Item | Average Price |
|---|---|
| Five Guys Milkshake | $5.99–$7.49 |
Customers aren’t simply paying for a vanilla shake. The price reflects hand-spun preparation, generous portions, premium ingredients, and one of the most customizable milkshakes available at a national burger chain.
Five Guys Milkshake Flavors & Mix-Ins
Rather than offering preset flavors, Five Guys lets customers build their own shake by combining complimentary mix-ins with its signature vanilla base.
Available Mix-Ins
| Mix-In | Flavor Profile |
|---|---|
| Oreo® Cookie Pieces | Crunchy chocolate cookie |
| Oreo® Crème | Sweet vanilla cream |
| Peanut Butter | Rich and nutty |
| Chocolate | Classic chocolate |
| Coffee | Bold coffee flavor |
| Salted Caramel | Sweet with a hint of salt |
| Banana | Fresh and creamy |
| Strawberries | Fruity and refreshing |
| Bacon | Sweet and smoky |
| REESE’S® Cups | Chocolate and peanut butter |
| Blackberry* | Sweet berry flavor (limited-time at participating locations) |
*Some participating locations may occasionally offer limited-time or seasonal mix-ins such as Blackberry or Candy Cane Crunch. Availability varies by restaurant and may not be offered year-round.
Because you can combine multiple complimentary mix-ins in a single shake, there are countless flavor combinations to explore.
Five Guys Milkshake Nutrition
Calories are only one part of the nutritional picture. Fat, sugar, protein, and portion size also influence how filling a shake is and whether it fits your dietary goals.
A plain Five Guys Milkshake starts with the restaurant’s signature vanilla base. Every mix-in changes the final nutrition values, so shakes with multiple ingredients naturally contain more calories, sugar, and fat than a plain vanilla shake.
| Item | Serving | Calories | Fat | Saturated Fat | Carbs | Sugar | Protein | Sodium |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla Shake Base | 396g | 670 | 32g | 21g | 84g | 82g | 13g | 360mg |
| Whipped Cream | 7g | 20 | 1.5g | 1g | 1g | 1g | 0g | 0mg |
| Bacon (2 Pieces) | 14g | 70 | 6g | 2g | 0g | 0g | 5g | 210mg |
| Banana | 80g | 160 | <1g | 0g | 51g | 44g | 1g | 5mg |
| Candy Cane Crunch* | 48g | 185 | 0g | 0g | 48g | 33g | 0g | 2mg |
| Chocolate | 50g | 133 | 2g | 2g | 30g | 22g | 2g | 30mg |
| Oreo® Crème | 50g | 320 | 25g | 7g | 23g | 23g | 0g | 48mg |
| Oreo® Cookie Pieces | 25g | 120 | 5g | 1g | 18g | 10g | 1g | 86mg |
| Peanut Butter | 50g | 322 | 29g | 5g | 9g | 4g | 9g | 218mg |
| REESE’S® Peanut Butter Cups | 28g | 150 | 8g | 3g | 15g | 14g | 3g | 98mg |
| Salted Caramel | 50g | 155 | <1g | <1g | 37g | 28g | <1g | 290mg |
| Strawberry | 60g | 90 | 0g | 0g | 17g | 23g | <1g | 2mg |
Note: Nutrition values are based on the vanilla shake base plus manufacturer-provided values for individual mix-ins. Because every Five Guys Milkshake is made to order, the final nutrition depends on the mix-ins you choose. Seasonal mix-ins, such as Candy Cane Crunch, may only be available at participating locations.
Five Guys Milkshake Recipe (Easy Copycat Recipe)
One of the best things about a Five Guys Milkshake is that it’s surprisingly easy to recreate at home. The secret isn’t a long list of ingredients—it’s using a rich vanilla ice cream, whole milk, and a few high-quality mix-ins. Just like the restaurant, you can customize every shake to match your favorite flavor combination.
Whether you love the classic vanilla taste, a rich chocolate shake, or the famous peanut butter and bacon combination, this simple recipe gives you the same thick, creamy texture that’s made Five Guys milkshakes so popular.
Ingredients
For one large milkshake, you’ll need:
- 3 large scoops premium vanilla ice cream
- ¾ cup cold whole milk (add a little more if you prefer a thinner shake)
- Whipped cream (optional)
Choose your favorite mix-ins:
- Oreo® Cookie Pieces
- Peanut Butter
- Chocolate syrup
- Coffee syrup
- Salted Caramel
- Fresh Banana
- Fresh Strawberries
- Crushed REESE’S® Cups
- Crispy bacon pieces
How to Make It
Step 1: Chill your glass
Place your serving glass in the freezer for about 10 minutes. A cold glass helps keep the milkshake thick for longer.
Step 2: Blend the base
Add the vanilla ice cream and cold milk to a blender. Blend for about 30 seconds until smooth, creamy, and thick.
Step 3: Add your mix-ins
Choose one to three mix-ins and blend again for another 10–15 seconds. Using only a few flavors allows each ingredient to stand out instead of getting lost in the mix.
Step 4: Adjust the consistency
If the shake feels too thick, add a small splash of milk. If it’s too thin, blend in another scoop of vanilla ice cream until you reach your preferred consistency.
Step 5: Serve immediately
Pour the milkshake into your chilled glass, top with whipped cream if you’d like, and enjoy it right away while it’s cold and creamy.
Best Homemade Flavor Combinations
If you’re not sure which flavors to try first, these combinations are some of the most popular among Five Guys fans:
| Flavor Combination | Why You’ll Love It |
|---|---|
| Peanut Butter + Banana | Rich, creamy, and naturally sweet |
| Oreo® Cookie Pieces + Peanut Butter | A cookies-and-cream favorite |
| Coffee + Chocolate | Smooth mocha flavor |
| Strawberry + Banana | Light, fruity, and refreshing |
| Salted Caramel + Bacon | Sweet and savory |
| Chocolate + REESE’S® Cups | Perfect for chocolate lovers |
Pro Tips for the Best Results
- Use premium vanilla ice cream for the richest flavor.
- Whole milk creates the smoothest texture.
- Blend only until smooth—over-blending can make the shake thin.
- Two or three mix-ins usually create the best balance of flavor.
- Serve immediately for the thick, hand-spun texture that makes a Five Guys Milkshake so enjoyable.
Homemade Tip: If you’re trying to recreate the authentic restaurant experience, pair your milkshake with fresh burgers and crispy fries. Many fans also dip their fries into a vanilla or peanut butter milkshake for the classic sweet-and-salty combination that’s become a Five Guys tradition.
Five Guys Milkshake Ingredients
Every Five Guys Milkshake begins with a rich vanilla shake base before your selected mix-ins are blended in.
Vanilla Shake Base
- Milkfat and nonfat milk
- Sugar
- Whey
- Natural and artificial flavors
- Stabilizers and emulsifiers
Optional whipped cream is available as a topping.
Depending on your customization, your shake may also include fresh fruit, Oreo® Cookie Pieces, Peanut Butter, Coffee syrup, Chocolate, Salted Caramel, Bacon, or REESE’S® Peanut Butter Cups.
Because every shake is made to order, the final ingredient list depends entirely on the mix-ins you choose.
Five Guys Milkshake Calories
A regular vanilla shake contains approximately 670 calories before any mix-ins are added. Each additional ingredient increases the calorie count depending on the flavor you choose.
Calories shown below are approximate and may vary slightly depending on portion size, selected mix-ins, and restaurant preparation.
| Item | Approx. Calories |
|---|---|
| Vanilla Shake Base | 670 |
| Whipped Cream | +20 |
| Banana | +160 |
| Strawberries | +90 |
| Chocolate | +133 |
| Peanut Butter | +322 |
| Oreo® Cookie Pieces | +120 |
| Oreo® Crème | +320 |
| Salted Caramel | +155 |
| Coffee | +27 |
| Bacon | +70 |
| REESE’S® Cups | +150 |
Nutrition Tip
Fruit-based combinations such as Strawberry + Banana generally add fewer calories than dessert-style combinations featuring Peanut Butter, Oreo® Crème, and REESE’S® Cups. If you’re trying to enjoy a lighter dessert, fruit mix-ins are usually the better choice.
Five Guys Milkshake Best Combos
One of the biggest reasons people love a Five Guys Milkshake is the freedom to create their own flavor combination. While there are countless possibilities, some pairings consistently stand out because they balance sweetness, texture, and richness.
| Combination | Best For |
|---|---|
| Peanut Butter + Banana | Creamy classic |
| Oreo® Cookie Pieces + Peanut Butter | Rich dessert lovers |
| Coffee + Chocolate | Mocha flavor |
| Strawberry + Banana | Fruity and refreshing |
| Salted Caramel + Bacon | Sweet and savory |
| Chocolate + REESE’S® Cups | Chocolate lovers |
| Oreo® Cookie Pieces + Chocolate | Cookies & cream lovers |
| Banana + Peanut Butter + Bacon | Famous Elvis-inspired combination |
Ordering Insight
Because every complimentary mix-in costs the same, choosing two or three flavors usually provides better value than selecting only one. However, adding too many ingredients can overpower the vanilla base, so most fans find that two to three mix-ins create the most balanced shake.
Can You Customize a Five Guys Milkshake?
Yes. Customization is one of the biggest reasons the Five Guys Milkshake stands out from many other fast-food desserts.
Every shake begins with the same vanilla base, after which your chosen mix-ins are blended together by hand. There are no preset flavor combinations, allowing you to build your own dessert exactly the way you like it.
Popular customization choices include:
- Chocolate + Peanut Butter
- Oreo® Cookie Pieces + Peanut Butter
- Coffee + Chocolate
- Banana + Peanut Butter
- Strawberry + Banana
- Salted Caramel + Bacon
This made-to-order approach means two customers can order completely different shakes even though they start with the same vanilla base.
Are Five Guys Milkshakes Gluten-Free?
The vanilla shake base itself does not contain gluten ingredients. However, some mix-ins—such as Oreo® Cookie Pieces—contain wheat.
Since all shakes are prepared using shared equipment, there is also a possibility of cross-contact during preparation.
Anyone with gluten sensitivity or celiac disease should review the restaurant’s latest allergen information or speak with the staff before ordering.
Five Guys Milkshake Allergens
Depending on the mix-ins you select, a Five Guys Milkshake may contain several common allergens.
| Allergen | Found In |
|---|---|
| Milk | Vanilla base, whipped cream, chocolate, caramel, REESE’S® Cups |
| Peanuts | Peanut Butter, REESE’S® Cups |
| Soy | Chocolate, Oreo® Crème, Oreo® Cookie Pieces, REESE’S® Cups |
| Wheat | Oreo® Cookie Pieces |
| Tree Nuts | Possible cross-contact in some ingredients |
Because every shake is made by hand, ingredient cross-contact is possible. Guests with food allergies should always verify the latest allergen information before placing an order.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is a Five Guys Milkshake?
A Five Guys Milkshake typically costs between $5.99 and $7.49, although prices may vary slightly by restaurant location. Every shake includes complimentary mix-ins, so adding extra flavors doesn’t usually increase the price.
How many calories are in a Five Guys Milkshake?
A plain vanilla Five Guys Milkshake contains about 670 calories before any mix-ins are added. The total calorie count increases depending on the ingredients you choose.
What are the best Five Guys Milkshake combinations?
Some of the most popular combinations include:
- Peanut Butter + Banana
- Oreo® Cookie Pieces + Peanut Butter
- Coffee + Chocolate
- Strawberry + Banana
- Salted Caramel + Bacon
- Chocolate + REESE’S® Cups
Can you customize a Five Guys Milkshake?
Yes. Every shake starts with the restaurant’s signature vanilla base, and you can add multiple complimentary mix-ins to create your own custom flavor.
Does every Five Guys location sell milkshakes?
Most U.S. locations offer milkshakes, but availability may vary. It’s always a good idea to check with your local restaurant before visiting.
Which mix-in adds the most calories?
Among the standard mix-ins, Peanut Butter and Oreo® Crème contribute the largest calorie increase, while fruit mix-ins such as strawberries and bananas generally add fewer calories.
Can you order a Five Guys Milkshake without whipped cream?
Yes. Whipped cream is optional, so you can request your shake without it if you want to reduce calories or simply prefer a plain shake.
What is the healthiest Five Guys Milkshake combination?
For a lighter option, many guests choose the vanilla base with Strawberries, Banana, or both, and skip the whipped cream. Fruit-based combinations typically contain fewer calories than dessert-style options made with Peanut Butter, Oreo® Crème, or REESE’S® Cups.
What makes Five Guys Milkshakes different from other fast-food milkshakes?
Unlike many fast-food chains that serve pre-mixed shakes, Five Guys Milkshakes are hand-spun after you order using a premium vanilla base. The ability to add multiple complimentary mix-ins also gives customers far more customization than most competing restaurants.
Conclusion
The Five Guys Milkshake continues to stand out because of its rich hand-spun vanilla base, fresh made-to-order preparation, and extensive customization options. Instead of choosing from a limited list of preset flavors, customers can mix complimentary ingredients like Peanut Butter, Oreo® Cookie Pieces, Chocolate, Coffee, Banana, Strawberries, Salted Caramel, Bacon, and more to create a shake that suits their own taste.
Before ordering, it’s worth comparing Five Guys Milkshake prices, calories, nutrition facts, ingredients, and mix-in combinations so you can choose an option that matches both your cravings and your dietary preferences. Since every shake includes complimentary mix-ins, adding two or three carefully selected flavors often provides the best balance of taste and value without overwhelming the classic vanilla base.
Whether you prefer a simple vanilla shake, a fruity blend, or a rich dessert packed with chocolate and peanut butter, the Five Guys Milkshake remains one of the most customizable and satisfying milkshakes available at a national burger chain.